MAGA Networks Turning on Each Other
/
In a dramatic escalation of the rivalry for conservative American viewership, right-wing media giant Fox News is facing an antitrust lawsuit from its smaller but aggressive competitor, Newsmax.
On Wednesday, Newsmax, led by CEO and Trump confidant Christopher Ruddy, filed a federal lawsuit accusing Fox Corp. of operating an illegal monopoly. The suit, lodged in the Southern District of Florida, alleges that Fox News leverages its market dominance as a "must-have" channel for cable distributors to systematically stifle competition.
According to the complaint, Fox coerces cable and satellite providers into contracts that either refuse to carry competing right-leaning channels like Newsmax or marginalize them with unfavorable placement and terms. Newsmax claims this "exclusionary scheme" is designed to maintain Fox's lucrative grip on the conservative pay-TV news market.
"Fox may have profited from exclusionary contracts and intimidation tactics for years, but those days are over," Ruddy declared in a statement. He argued that the legal action aims to "restore fairness" and ensure Americans have a "real choice in the news they watch."
Newsmax is seeking significant monetary damages, which it notes could be tripled under federal antitrust law, and a court order to dismantle what it calls Fox’s "monopolistic practices."
Fox News responded with, “Newsmax cannot sue their way out of their own competitive failures in the marketplace to chase headlines simply because they can’t attract viewers.”
Analysis: How the "Trump-Loving Media" is Turning on Each Other
This lawsuit represents a significant fracture within the conservative media ecosystem, which largely found a common cause and audience during the Trump presidency. Here’s how this event shows them turning on each other:
From Ideological Allies to Business Enemies: For years, Fox News and Newsmax, while competitors, were effectively on the same team in the larger culture war. They both catered to a conservative, pro-Trump audience and often amplified similar narratives. This lawsuit moves their conflict from the marketplace of ideas to a federal courtroom. Newsmax is no longer just trying to win over Fox's viewers; it's attempting to use the legal system to break Fox's business model.
A Challenge to the Undisputed King: Fox News has been the dominant force in conservative media for over two decades. Newsmax, which saw explosive growth by positioning itself as even more loyal to Donald Trump than Fox, is now making a direct assault on the foundations of Fox's power. The lawsuit essentially claims Fox's success isn't due to a superior product, but to illegal, anti-competitive tactics. It’s a move to dethrone the king, not just compete with him.
Weaponizing Free-Market Rhetoric Against Each Other: Both networks champion free-market capitalism. However, Newsmax is now accusing Fox of being a monopolistic bully that violates the core principles of fair competition. Christopher Ruddy's statement about "restoring fairness to the market" and giving Americans "real choice" co-opts the very language of market freedom that both networks preach in order to attack their chief rival.
A Battle for Money, Not Just Viewers: At its heart, this is a fight over billions of dollars in cable subscription fees. Fox News commands high fees from distributors because it's considered essential. Newsmax wants a piece of that pie. This lawsuit reveals that behind the unified political messaging lies a cutthroat business rivalry where one ally is willing to inflict massive financial and legal damage on another for a larger share of the market. It exposes the raw financial motivations that underpin the political media landscape.
